Manhattan Love Story

Each time Dana (Analeigh Tipton) and Peter (Jake McDorman) are about to have sex, they end up in ridiculous fights; the most recent being about the movie Love Actually. Their friends plan a screening of the movie to help, which backfires, sparking yet another fight. But, finally, after Peter makes a romantic gesture inspired by a character in the movie, the two of them have sex. David (Nicolas Wright) and Chloe (Chloe Wepper) help William (Kurt Fuller) hunt down his biggest critic after he comes across negative reviews about his company on Yelp. David and Amy finally forgive each other for that first fight from so many years ago.

An impending storm is a fitting end to a tough week for Dana (Analeigh Tipton) until her boss calls with her first book to edit due first thing Monday. But when everyone she knows shows up at the office to wait out the storm, Dana is annoyed by the distraction until the power goes out and everyone pitches in to help her meet her deadline. Meanwhile, Peter (Jake McDorman) really wants Dana to sell her car but when his offer to help move it from the flood zone backfires (he doesn't know how to drive) he realizes he's just worried that she might someday want to use it to leave the city and him. Amy (Jade Catta-Preta) and David (Nicolas Wright) fight over the value of things in their apartment when David decides only to save his Han Solo statue from the storm.

Dana (Analeigh Tipton) is forced to reveal an embarrassing hobby (LARPing) to Peter (Jake McDorman) when he joins her on what he believes is an out of town work conference. But a supportive Peter eventually misses Dana and decides to join her on the playing field, putting everything she's worked so hard for and loves about the game in jeopardy. Meanwhile at Cooper & Sons, when an important client suddenly wants to come in for his annual meeting, the family is afraid David (Nicolas Wright) might not have the necessary skills to close the deal without Peter.

When Dana (Analeigh Tipton) replaces Peter (Jake McDorman) with Tucker as her plus one to an old friend's wedding, Peter quickly realizes that he'd rather have a miserable time with Dana than a wonderful time without her. Amy (Jade Catta-Preta) skips her spin class to secretly take dance lessons in preparation for the wedding and David (Nicolas Wright) thinks she might be having an affair.

Peter (Jake McDorman) is embarrassed by his family and doesn't invite Dana (Analeigh Tipton) to Thanksgiving until he knows she has plans to go home and can't make it. But when Dana's flight home suddenly gets cancelled, she ends up in the middle of Peter's horribly family Thanksmas tradition and is determined to turn things around and have fun.

When Peter (Jake McDorman) learns that Dana (Analeigh Tipton) is still friends with all of her exes, even the one who proposed, he takes her cue and tries to reconnect with his one long-term girlfriend and things go horribly wrong. There is conflict at Cooper & Sons when Amy (Jade Catta-Preta) fills in for the receptionist and tries to tell everyone how to do their job.

When Dana (Analeigh Tipton's ex-boyfriend shows up in New York to win her back, Peter (Jake McDorman) does everything he can to show Dana how much he cares, even letting her go if that's what it takes. David (Nicolas Wright) helps Chloe (Chloe Wepper) get out of her dating slump by showing her how to use the Cooper family secret dating trophy.