Find My First Love

Matthew met his first love Courtney in High School. He was the introverted, tough kid and she was the one who was able to break down his walls. But after a dreamy prom date, Matthew felt insecure and ditched her to hang with friends. The decision caused a rift between them, and then life pulled them in different directions. Now Matthew realizes that she could have been the one that got away and wants a second shot at love!

Dennis met the stunning Agatha while studying abroad in Monaco during college. And for that year when they weren't cavorting on the French Riviera, they were traveling throughout Europe. It was a fairytale romance- and then it stopped- and he never heard from Agatha again. Now years later, Dennis is still pining for the love he found in Monaco, and needs to know if it was real or just a fantasy for Agatha.

When David first laid eyes on his grad school love Leanna, his heart skipped a beat and he was never the same. After a brief but memorable romance they drifted apart when she left to study abroad. Now 4 years later, David's dates never seem to compare to his dream girl Leanna. He wants to rekindle the spark,or find closure so he can close the book forever.

After 10 years in a loveless marriage, a newly divorced Alexis locked eyes with Priest one night in a club and the connection was instant. But after a few fun dates and late night phone calls, life pulled them apart when Priest got a job overseas playing basketball. He asked her to come with him, but she had 2 small children and new career that kept her in Chicago, so it ended and he vanished. Now 15 years later, she wants to rekindle the connection that was lost years ago.

Sarah met her Australian love when he was bartending at a Chicago bar. They spent a magical summer together, and then the free-spirited John left for the next stop on his global travels. A year later, he came back but she ghosted him because she was in a serious relationship. Now after splitting up with her boyfriend, her mind always wanders back to John and what might have been.

In the name of love, we clocked 58,000 miles and traveled to over 30 cities across the globe on a challenging mission to find the one who got away. Whether it was to reunite with a lost love or find closure, our determined romantics hopped on an emotional roller coaster that one moment took their breath away and just as swiftly filled it with agonizing heartache. Now we're taking a look back to see what happened after the TV cameras stopped rolling and loves pixie dust settled. Did our reunited lovers recreate the magic? Or did they go in opposite directions? Either way, it's time to celebrate the courageous souls who risked their hearts on the bumpy road to find true love!